Category: Nutrition

Sulforaphane_Autism_v2

Sulforaphane Improves Autism Symptoms

Normally, I would be sharing a new blog post with you today. In fact, I already had one lined up about the link between antidepressants and weight gain (which I hope you’ll check back for in a few days). However, just this week a press release from Massachusetts General Hospital (MGH) found its way to my inbox, and I was so caught by the results of the study they reported, that I want to immediately share it with all of you. What this study means for the treatment of autism is groundbreaking. 

Read MGH’s press release below, copied in its entirety, and view the original study here, for your reference. You can learn more about sulforaphane, the subject of this groundbreaking research as it relates to Parkinson’s disease, in this 2013 study.

BOSTON – A small study led by investigators at MassGeneral Hospital for Children (MGHfC) and Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine has found evidence that daily treatment with sulforaphane – a molecule found in foods such as broccoli, cauliflower and cabbage – may improve some symptoms of autism spectrum disorders. In their report being published online in PNAS Early Edition, the investigators describe how participants receiving a daily dose of sulforaphane showed improvement in both behavioral and communication assessments in as little as four weeks.

The authors stress that the results of this pilot study – conducted at the MGHfC-affiliated Lurie Center for Autism – must be confirmed in larger investigations before any conclusions can be drawn about sulforaphane’s therapeutic benefit. “Over the years there have been several anecdotal reports that children with autism can have improvements in social interaction and sometimes language skills when they have a fever,” explains Andrew Zimmerman, MD, a co-corresponding author of the current report who also published a 2007 paper documenting the fever effect. “We investigated what might be behind that on a cellular level and postulated that it results from fever’s activation of the cellular stress response, in which protective cellular mechanisms that are usually held in reserve are turned on through activation of gene transcription.” Affiliated with the MGHfC Department of Neurology, Zimmerman is now based at UMass Memorial Medical Center.  Sulforaphane was first isolated in the 1990s by Paul Talalay, MD – co-corresponding author of the PNAS Early Edition paper and now a professor of Pharmacology and Molecular Sciences at Johns Hopkins – and his group also found that the chemical supports key aspects of the cell stress response.  Zimmerman, who was based at Hopkins when he published the fever paper, approached members of Talalay’s team to propose investigating sulforaphane’s possible benefits for treating autism. While the mechanism underlying autism and other disorders on the autism spectrum remain largely unknown, several molecular abnormalities – including some related to the cellular stress response – have been identified. After Zimmerman moved to MGHfC in 2010, the trial was initiated at the Lurie Center in Lexington, Mass.

The study enrolled 44 young men, ages 13 to 27, who had been diagnosed with moderate to severe autism spectrum disorder. Participants were randomly assigned to a daily dose of either sulforaphane – extracted from broccoli sprouts – or a placebo, with neither investigators, participants nor their caregivers knowing who was receiving the study drug. Participants were assessed using standardized measurements of behavior and social interaction – some completed by caregivers, some by study staff – at the outset of the study and at 4, 10 and 18 weeks after treatment began. Treatment was discontinued after 18 weeks, and additional assessments of 22 participants were conducted 4 weeks later. Study lead author Kanwaljit Singh, MD, MPH – of MGHfC, the Lurie Center and UMass – says that among the 40 participants who returned for at least one evaluation, the average scores for each of the assessments were significantly better for the 26 participants receiving sulforaphane than for the 14 who received a placebo. Even at the 4-week visit, some caregivers reported a noticeable behavioral improvement, and by the end of the study period, both study staff and family members correctly guessed the assignments of many participants.

Overall, 17 of the 26 participants who received sulforaphane were judged by their caregivers to have improvements in behavior, social interaction and calmness while on active treatment. After 18 weeks of treatment, the average scores on two assessments – the Aberrant Behavior Checklist and Social Responsiveness Scale – of those who received sulforaphane had decreased 34 and 17 percent, respectively – indicating improvement in factors such as irritability, lethargy, repetitive movements, hyperactivity, communication, motivation and mannerisms. Assessments using the Clinical Global Impression scale indicated that 46 percent of sulforaphane recipients exhibited noticeable improvement in social interaction, 54 percent in aberrant behaviors, and 42 percent in verbal communication.

Most but not all of the improvements had disappeared by the 22-week reassessment, supporting the probability that changes had been the result of sulforaphane treatment. “When we broke the code that revealed who was receiving sulforaphane and who got the placebo, the results weren’t surprising to us, since the improvements were so noticeable,” says Zimmerman, now a professor of Pediatric Neurology at UMass. “The improvements seen on the Social Responsiveness Scale were particularly remarkable, and I’ve been told this is the first time that any statistically significant improvement on the SRS has been seen for a drug study in autism spectrum disorder. “But it’s important to note that the improvements didn’t affect everyone – about one third had no improvement – and the study must be repeated in a larger group of adults and in children, something we’re hoping to organize soon,” he adds. “Ultimately we need to get at the biology underlying the effects we have seen and study it at a cellular level. I think that will be done, and I hope it will teach us a lot about this still poorly understood disorder.”

Additional co-authors of the PNAS study are Susan Connors, MD, MGHfC, Eric Macklin, PhD, MGH Biostatistics; and Kirby Smith and Jed Fahey, Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine. The study was supported by grants from the Nancy Lurie Marks Family Foundation, the Hussman Foundation, the Lewis B. and Dorothy Cullman Foundation, the Agnes Gund Foundation, the N of One Foundation and the Brassica Foundation for Chemoprotection Research.

Massachusetts General Hospital, founded in 1811, is the original and largest teaching hospital of Harvard Medical School. The MGH conducts the largest hospital-based research program in the United States, with an annual research budget of more than $785 million and major research centers in HIV/AIDS, cardiovascular research, cancer, computational and integrative biology, cutaneous biology, human genetics, medical imaging, neurodegenerative disorders, regenerative medicine, reproductive biology, systems biology, transplantation biology and photomedicine.

What the authors concluded was that the activity of sulforaphane in terms of activating the Nrf2 pathway was likely the reason for its success. The Nrf2 gene pathway, when activated, dramatically reduces inflammation in the brain while increasing antioxidant protection. Sulforaphane is a powerful activator of Nrf2 and this is the reason we have included it in Nrf2 Advantage. Nrf2 Advantage has become one of my top nutritional supplements that we use in our clinic.

  • Christine

    Great article.
    The author states that Nrf2 dramatically reduces inflammation in the brain while increasing antioxidant protection.
    Dr. Perlmutter, my son has sensory integration dysfunction along with borderline ADD and is recovering from a concussion. Do you think Nrf2 is something he may benefit from? If not, do you have any recommendations for him?
    Thank you for all you do Dr. Perlmutter

    • 40.00 Nrf2 Synergizer

      This is a great comparison of Sulforaphane to other available Nrf2 activators:

      http://registration.akm.ch/einsicht.php?XNABSTRACT_ID=137548&XNSPRACHE_ID=2&XNKONGRESS_ID=150&XNMASKEN_ID=900

      Other studies can be found on the NIH site http://www.pubmed.gov

      To order (40.00/month): http://www.lifevantage.com/nowageless

    • David Perlmutter

      In this situation I use a higher fat, lower carb, gluten-free diet with vitamin D, aggressive probiotics and nutritional supplementation designed to enhance the Nrf2 pathway.

      • Christine

        Dr Perlmutter, Thank you for the info but how does one go about getting the right probiotics and nutritional supplementation that are designed to enhance the Nrf2 pathway? Do you have a specific book with this info or do you give phone consultations?

        • David Perlmutter

          Christine: I would start with this blog post on the supplement regimen I advise. drperlmutter.com/grain-brain-seven-super-supplements/

  • 40.00 Nrf2Synergizer
  • Pingback: More Good News About Nrf2 | David Perlmutter M.D.()

  • Pingback: Do You Know The Power of the Nrf2 Pathway? | David Perlmutter M.D.()

  • Milou

    Dr. Perlmutter, thank you for the post. I have a 15-yr-old son and a 9-yr-old daughter that are on the spectrum with mainly motor and speech delays. They both attend mainstream schools with support as their processing speed is holding them back. They both had bilateral cataracts at the age of seven and four respectively. We have done an extensive axiom testing at Cedar Sinai a couple of years back but could not pinpoint the cause. My daughter craves brocolli and cauliflower all the time and prefers them raw; which I find very interesting after reading your article. She is currently on Co-Q10, B2, B12, and fatty acids. Would you recommend adding Nrf2? Thank you.

    • David Perlmutter

      An Nrf2 activating supplement is always something I advise. However, consult with their pediatrician first before making any changes to their regimen. I wish them, and you, the very best of health.

  • Bakunin

    This is a great article that I come back to from time to time. I know this article is old, but David could you please answer this question. I am not autistic (that I know of) but my brain functioning also greatly increases when I have a fever. Normally, I am depressed, lethargic, unmotivated, have brain fog, and have trouble with communication, yet sill have a high IQ. When I have a fever (either from sickness or even when I was withdrawing from Klonopin) I often get motivated, am happy, don’t have brain fog, and do not have trouble communicating. I feel more normal. Could the same thing be happening in my brain. A kind of chronic inflammation temporarily healed by the anti-inflammatory processes induced by the fever? Should I try this cruciferous supplement?

    • Eddie Garza

      Hi Bakunin, I hope you are well. I am kind of the same situation as you described. Have you tried the Sulforaphane yet? Is so, how has it worked for you? I just ordered the product in addition to the other supplements mentioned. Thanks

      sulforaphane
      sulforaphane

Loading More